• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Fat Sully’s Pizza

Fat Sully’s Pizza, located in Denver, offers a variety of NY style pizza options with thin, crispy crusts and flavorful toppings. Customers rave about the buttery biscuits and the smashed burger, highlighting the diverse menu. The service is praised for being speedy and efficient, creating a positive dining experience. With a welcoming ambiance and a range of happy hour specials, Fat Sully’s is a go-to spot for those craving delicious pizza and unique menu offerings in Denver. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a late-night bite, Fat Sully's has something for everyone to enjoy.

LOCATIONS
  • Fat Sully’s Pizza
    3237 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206, United States
    3237 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206, United States Hotline: +1 303-339-3977

Introducing Fat Sully’s Pizza, a haven for lovers of New York style pizza in Denver. Located at 3237 E Colfax Ave, this pizza joint offers a wide range of amenities including delivery, takeout, reservations, vegan options, and a full bar. The restaurant caters to a casual crowd, with moderate noise levels, outdoor seating, and even happy hour specials.

Customer reviews rave about the generous portions and delicious flavors at Fat Sully’s. From massive biscuits at Denver Biscuit Company to perfectly crispy thin crust pizzas, the menu here is sure to satisfy any craving. If you're a fan of New York slices, the crispy, chewy crust, flavorful sauce, and minimal flop will have you coming back for more.

Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast biscuit sandwich, a classic slice of pizza, or a $6 slice and beer combo, Fat Sully’s has something for everyone. Don't miss out on their smashed burger, cheesy and flavorful, or the loaded pizzas with fresh basil and perfectly baked crust. And if you're in a hurry, ordering online for a quick pick-up or delivery is a breeze.

So if you find yourself in Denver and craving a slice of authentic New York pizza, look no further than Fat Sully’s Pizza. With its diverse menu, welcoming atmosphere, and impeccable service, this restaurant will leave you satisfied and coming back for more.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Fat Sully’s Pizza
Amanda L.
Amanda L.

OMG Denver Biscuit Company (also falls under the name of Atomic Cowboy/Fat Sully's) is absolutely fantastic! Their biscuits are some of the butteriest, moistest, flakiest biscuits I've ever had! I'm glad there are a handful of DBC locations throughout the city of Denver so the wealth is well spread. We came here for breakfast and I like that this DBC in particular is housed in the same space as two other restaurants, so that there's food options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and a wide variety of it all as well. Given that it was breakfast though, we all ordered the biscuits and what a hearty breakfast it was! These biscuits are massive - frankly, everything here comes in massive proportions including the largest cinnamon roll I've ever seen! Not only are the biscuits massive, but they're essentially sandwiches and come piled on with a ton of ingredients as well! I ordered the K-Mack biscuit sandwich, which had a Korean spin on all of it. It was Korean fried buttermilk chicken (so tender and flavorful!), toasted sesame seeds, sesame mayo, pickled daikon (the perfect burst of tart freshness - could've done with even more given how heavy all the other ingredients are), shredded cabbage, and green onions. The chicken was perfect, the biscuit was perfect, my belly was wildly happy! On top of it all, I added a side of McHashbrowns because I had to try what these were, given that I do really enjoy the McDonald's hashbrowns. These ended up being some of the best hashbrowns I've ever had. Twice the thickness of a McDonald's hashbrown and in a triangle shape, perfectly crispy on the outside and potato-y on the inside! It was way too much food and easily split into two full meals, but it was so worth it! The giant biscuit cinnamon roll that my friends and I ordered was so good as well. Like I said earlier in this review, it was truly massive and we also added the option of the bacon bits on top because we wanted to try that out. The result was delicious - salty and sweet! And even among the three of us, we couldn't finish the cinnamon roll given that we each had ordered biscuit sandwiches as well. We all ended up taking leftovers home for another meal in addition to not even being hungry by the time dinner rolled around that same day, even after a ton of hiking and exploring! Denver Biscuit Co. is worth all of it and then some! You won't regret coming here and are sure to leave SUPER satisfied!

Michaela S.
Michaela S.

Great place for NY style pizza in Denver! Idk why the reviews for this place are such a mixed bag, but I *almost* let that stop me from trying it out. On a whim, I ordered delivery for lunch because I didn't have time to go out and grab food. So I can't speak to the ambiance of the restaurant or the staff unfortunately. The pizza arrived hot, fresh, and earlier than the stated timeframe. (Kudos to my delivery driver, she was great!) The pizza was HUGE and tasted great. It had that crispy/chewing crust but was thin enough to fold in half. Just perfect. I ate two slices and was more than satisfied. There were 8 slices total, so plenty for leftovers! S/N: I love that they have the ordering and delivery process fully integrated. I just went to Fat Sully's website and checked out. No need to install a million apps or go to another wesbite. Now my only regret is not ordering the waffle fries, but I'll just have to try those next time. The dessert options looked good too. I definitely recommend giving this place a try. Either stop in for a slice or grab a whole pie via delivery!

Cesar H.
Cesar H.

I'm very surprised by the lower reviews. I've had nothing but good experiences at this location. I've tried the pizza which is delicious and the biscuits for breakfast which are always a hit. My review today is more about their smashed burger. It was outstanding! The beef was flavorful and the burger was cheesy with soft pillowy buns. The service is always good and it is a very low key place which is my favorite kind of vibe. I wish they would take reservations but if you join the waitlist, it rarely takes long to be seated

Rostam Z.
Rostam Z.

I don't know what's with all the negative reviews. This slice was very very good and truly a New York slice. Thin, crispy, slight chew, everything I'm looking for in an NY slice. Sauce was on point and not too overpowering and it's was cooked to perfection. Minimal to no flop which is the first sign of a good slice. So far, this is my favorite slice in Denver.

Ruba A.
Ruba A.

The pizza was everything I needed that day. Loaded with fresh basil just like I asked and it's always baked to the perfect temperature. The service was speedy.

Tony M.
Tony M.

Came for the $6 slice and beer combo with a side of the Cesar salad Must try especially for a random meal on a Monday. Service was ok today and ambiance is always great

Sarah G.
Sarah G.

We were reaching approaching dangerous levels of hanger and decided to check out this pizza place right around the corner from us. Pieces are big, thin New York style pizza. It hit the spot. Ratios were good and the crust has a nice crunch to it while still offering a little bit of doughiness. There was quite a bit of grease dripping off our pieces, so make sure to grab some napkins for clean up afterwards. We ordered online and got our pizza within 20 minutes, freshly baked right out of the oven. We were able to snag one of the few seats new the outdoor window and enjoy the nice spring evening. I know I will be back here again while in Denver